St. John Hotel Reviews
Summary of All Destination Reviews - Ratings based on answers from a total of 13 reviews 10 is fantastic 1 is terrible
Cleanliness of Destination/Island
Options of Activities in the Area
Ease of Transportation (air, taxi, bus, shuttle) 8.54
Quality of Beaches
Courtesy & Hospitality of Locals
Safety Factor (Did you feel safe in the Area)
Local Restaurant Experience/Options
Price/Value of Destination (Does your dollar stretch?)
8.87 out of 10 based on 13 reviews
100% (13 visitors of 13) said they would go back to
St. John again. 100% (13 visitors of 13) said they would recommend
St. John to friends. Highest Rated St. John Hotels: Starlit Escape Villa (St. John) : 4.50 Stars based on reviews 4 Estate Lindholm (St. John) : 5.00 Stars based on reviews 3 Tradewinds Cottage (St. John) : 5.00 Stars based on reviews 2 Serendip Vacation Condos (St. John) : 5.00 Stars based on reviews 2 Hillcrest Guest House, St. John US Virgin Islands (St. John) : 5.00 Stars based on 1 review Calabash Cottages - St. John (St. John) : 5.00 Stars based on 1 review Maho Bay (St. John) : 4.00 Stars based on 1 review St. John Villas by Donald Schnell (St. John) : 5.00 Stars based on 1 review The Westin St. John Resort & Villas (St. John) : 5.00 Stars based on 1 review Individual Reviews ordered by date submitted:
(Date of Visit: June 2005) St. John Villas by Donald Schnell - Review
: My husband and I stayed at the beach estate in June of 05 on St John for 12 days. The villa was IMMACUATE, relaxing and lovely ...
Wonderful relaxing experience
(Date of Visit: January 2007) Calabash Cottages - St. John - Review
: My wife and I stayed in the sago cottage, and it was the most enjoyable stay we have ever had. The cottage is better than the ...
(Date of Visit: August 2007) Starlit Escape Villa - Review
: I read the reviews a nd could not find recent ones....this worried me. We stayed in late August 2007. It's true, the place is ...
(Date of Visit: March 2007) Caneel Bay - Review
: We had a delightful time at Caneel Bay. Its expensive, sure, but you get what you pay for. The service was top-notch. We ...
(Date of Visit: November 2006) Tradewinds Cottage - Review
: Lois and Doug, The Tradewinds Cottage was
all that we had hoped it would be: spectacular
views, refreshing breezes, clean ...
Tradewinds Cottage, St. John
(Date of Visit: March 2006) Tradewinds Cottage - Review
: Thank you for helping us have a truly relaxing vacation. Having stayed at Cruz Bay several times we weren't sure about returning ...
Tradewinds Cottage, St. John
(Date of Visit: November 2006) The Westin St. John Resort & Villas - Review
: Thanksgiving, 2005 stayed at villa adjacent to westin.Thanksgiving, 2006 would like to rent a three bedroom villa which I toured ...
(Date of Visit: April 2006) Serendip Vacation Condos - Review
: We have stayed in Alpha unit at Serendip the past 5 times we have been to Serendip. It has become our second home. Alpha is ...
Best value on St. John
(Date of Visit: May 2005) Maho Bay - Review
: Arthur Frommer stated in USA Today when he was asked what his favorite hotel in all the world was: 'In all the world Maho Bay ...
An unpretentious paradise
(Date of Visit: April 2005) Serendip Vacation Condos - Review
: We stayed at another property on St. John. It was our Fourth time on the island. We decided to look at condos, thinking we would ...
Loved it so much......Decided to Buy it !
(Date of Visit: March 2005) Hillcrest Guest House, St. John US Virgin Islands - Review
: I loved staying at the hillcrestguesthouse it was beautiful, the room was extremely comfortable and the view was breath taking. ...
I loved it , it was the most beautiful
(Date of Visit: March 2005) Starlit Escape Villa - Review
: We stayed at Starlit Escape on this our third visit to St. John. The villa was just right for us (3 couples). There's a master ...
Quality - and the price is right
(Date of Visit: August 2004) Estate Lindholm - Review
: My wife and I spent our weeklong vacation at the Estate Lindholm in Aug 2004. We had the Rendevous room that overlooks Cruz Bay. ...
We are bringing the entire family next time!
(Date of Visit: March 2004) Caneel Bay - Review
: Save your money. Or, go to a $79/night motel in Florida and burn $800 a day. They do have a nice shallow beach if you have small ...
(Date of Visit: December 2003) Starlit Escape Villa - Review
: We stayed in the Starlit suite with 2 other couples. It was fantastic. Immaculately clean, huge, quite. Everything worked! It ...
(Date of Visit: October 2003) Estate Lindholm - Review
: We chose to stay at Estate Lindholm while celebrating our 25th anniversary. We were looking for something fairly quiet, romantic ...
(Date of Visit: September 2003) Estate Lindholm - Review
: My wife and I were looking for an intimate vacation in a location where we had easy access to beaches and restaurants. We had ...
(Date of Visit: June 2003) Starlit Escape Villa - Review
: We didn't actually stay at Starlit Escape - we had seen it on the Internet so when we got to St. John we gave the owner a call ( ...
Starlit Escape Villa
Submit Your Own Review: To submit your own review, click into a individual property profile and submit your review from the property reviews page.
Related St. John Accommodations
View All St. John Hotels, Resorts, Villas & Condos